Independent Investigations – The Importance of Equilibrium

Inquiry Question: What were the impacts of the fur trading industry (Hudson’s Bay, Northwest Company, and people) on the Canadian environment/landscape?

During the colonization of the New World by the Europeans, many settlers saw an opportunity of wealth and sought to find riches such as gold. To their surprise, they found something just as good; animal fur.

Fur played a huge part in the success of the new colonies. Bringing in a profit meant investments from Europe, which in turn translated to the growth of European communities in North America. But this seemingly endless supply of fur, was to no surprise, finite. Due to over trapping and hunting of fur, populations of beaver, and other fur bearing animals, were pushed to near-extinct levels. Hundreds of thousands of furs were exported to Europe each year. Thankfully, nearing the 19th century, the paradigm of fashion in Europe transitioned towards silk, relieving the pressure for fur.

 

Cause and Consequence

To look at why things happened the way they did, we must look at the wants and fears of the historical actors present during the events. Commonly, settlers sailing towards the great new land searched for a new life and opportunity. A more opulent life than to the one which they had left behind. Although they dreamed of success, they had rolled a dice. Accepted a gamble. They faced having to raise money in a young economy. These desires pushed the new citizens to search for a profit. And during that period, fur was plentiful, expensive, and accessible. A perfect calling for a business.

At first, the mark left by humanity was not noticeable. The colonies were small, and businesses small in number. But as time passed, more people got involved, more people joined in. And by the turn of the century, beaver populations are speculated to have dropped by 80-90%. The mass spread of colonization additionally brought a wave of towns, forts, and posts to a continent previously covered in flora and fauna.

To picture the amount of decrease in the population, the image below shows how long a line of 60 million beavers (estimated beaver population before fur trade) would be compared to the US-Canadian Border. Each Centimeter represents 1000km, each tick represents roughly the length of the border (6,400km), and the spikes you see next to the beaver image is just to conserve space on the paper.

20180411_215247

Yeah, that’s a lot of beavers, but why does that matter? Of course there would be many of them! But if you look carefully, the part of the line highlighted in blue represents the same line of beavers at the start of the 19th century (or two of those if you are optimistic).

 

Continuity and Change

During the fur trade, the historical actors abused the natural resources and nearly depleted the populations of entire species such as beaver. Their wants and fears forced them to look upon money, and not the environment. We see a similar story today, with the constant use of different natural resources, burning up and emitting harmful substances into the air. If we take a peak into the past, we can see that businesses relying on the use of natural resources can alter the equilibrium of nature. The beaver is considered a “keystone” animal to Canada, providing and creating a suitable home to many other species (a key component to the ecosystem). An example of an abused “key” today is our air. Recently, I went on a trip to Korea, and there I witnessed the extents of pollution to the point were the Government had to send warnings


on your phone to NOT GO OUTSIDE.

To me this was an eye opener, we together, as a society, need to deeply consider the long term effects of the change we are capable of.

 

Final Thoughts

At first I thought this project was going to be simple, a nice easy DOL to end the week with. But it happened to become a lot bigger than I anticipated. I only had the chance to research about one animal (and topic). The beaver, which I thought to be the most important. But there are many other animals that were hunted during this time (e.g: Marten, Geese, Minks, Seals, Racoons, Otters, THE LIST GOES ON). Additionally, the question I wanted to better understand was not just about animals, but of the change to the environment as a whole. This would include things like new diseases carried by Europeans that harmed the communities and environments of the indigenous, to the change caused by the sudden eruption of human population.

However, with the research that I was able to complete, I can corroborate that the fur trading industry left a great mark in history. Rapidly changing the course of the continent by introducing new things, and taking away/decreasing important necessities.

 

Citations:

http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/fur-trade/

http://digital.library.mcgill.ca/nwc/history/01.htm

http://thefurbearers.com/what-we-do/living-with-wildlife/beavers/beavers-and-the-fur-trade

https://www.animaljustice.ca/blog/escaping-wild-history-canadas-fur-trade

https://eh.net/encyclopedia/the-economic-history-of-the-fur-trade-1670-to-1870/

http://www.hbcheritage.ca/classroom/virtual-museum/fur-trade-nation/the-growth-of-the-fur-trade

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beaver

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fur_trading_post_and_forts_in_North_America

http://owenc.talons43.ca/2018/04/03/dol-3-independent-canadian-inquiry/

http://thefurbearers.com/what-we-do/living-with-wildlife/beavers/about-beavers

 

4 thoughts on “Independent Investigations – The Importance of Equilibrium

  1. Hey Yoonha!
    Your blog post is spot on! I really like how you connected your blog post to personal experiences that you had and how you added a diagram to put things into perspective. The diagram you added put a lot of impact on how much the beaver population has decreased. That’s my first star. My second star is on how simple your blog post is. You didn’t waste any time talking about unnecessary information and told us what happened, how it happened and why it’s important. It made your blog post super easy to read!
    My blog post talks a lot about the Battle of the Plains of Abraham, and I think your blog post highlights the reason why the Battle of the Plains of Abraham happened in the first place. The British wanted to take over Quebec for the more land and resources, like animal fur, and your blog post shows how much animal fur was coveted, to the point where the beaver population decreased drastically.
    Your fellow TALONS,
    Grace. :))

  2. Hey Yoonha!

    My first star for your amazing inquiry is how organized and professional it is. I can tell by the language you use and the facts you give that you’re confident in your research and inquiry as a whole. I think that is very impressive and definitely makes your work a good and worthwhile read. My second star is your beaver diagram. It’s great that you took time out of writing your blog post to make a diagram that really emphasizes the info you’re giving about the beaver population and environmental change.

    A connection between my investigation and yours is that both beavers and the Filles du Roi were wanted for something that wasn’t necessarily in their best interest. The pursuit of beavers and other fur-bearing animals led to dangerous decreases in their population. All this was done for the fur that Europeans used to make clothing and other valuable items. The Filles du Roi were wanted to increase the population of New France. In other words, they were needed for children. Numerous women died on the turbulent voyage it took to transport them to New France, and others due to childbirth or their unsuitableness for the rough Canadian environment. The women may have chosen to participate voluntarily, but tht=at doesn’t make the damage caused any less important.

    Great inquiry,
    Ashley

  3. Hi Yoonha,
    I LOVED your use of hand-drawn pictures! They made your post really cool. I also really liked the parallels that you drew from the historic fur trade to the modern world. It connects to my topic because many Indigenous people relied on the fur trade as a source of steady wealth.
    Caitlin

  4. Sorry, but I realized that “cool” was a pretty vague term. I meant that the fact that you put so much work into your project made it really interesting, and I revere your drawing ability.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *